Human Weapon Aftermath
Well, I finally got to see the Human Weapon show. Many friends and family in the US got to see it before me and many had nice things to say, so thanks for your comments.
Of course, I had to withhold any comments on the show that revealed too much detail until it aired, so, I will take a few moments to comment now on the experience after viewing it.
The show seemed to turn out similar to what I can remember, and the challenge was interesting to watch. I do recall there were a few more things that happened that must have been cut for entertainments sake, but hey, that’s Hollywood, right. I do remember that putting the challenge together in the last minute was a bit on the fly, but we needed to come up with something that would work to meet the director and producers need for a challenge. With our art being being “non-competitive” it was a bit of a challenge in itself and I think the end product worked for the show and was resonably well done for the short time that we had to produce it. We also knew the risk that there will be people out there who will jump to the conclusion that it was ” representative” of what we do here in the BK. I do feel sorry that they did not have their chance to see what they imagine should have happened.
Unfortunately, what was requested as the challenge was denied, and therefore something had to be done to control the space. Not all Ninjas show their tricks. Silly Rabbit…
Turning BK into a sport, is tough and to adhere to rules is tougher and there were plenty of talks and conversation prior to avoid injury. And yes, even reality shows do have some level of control. The plastic goggles might have been safe, but they just did not look that cool on camera, so we chose to go without them.
All in all, Bill and Jason are great guys and they do have knowledge and abilities. Jason maybe more so, being a professional mixed martial artist, so it was a truly a training opportunity and learning experience for me, and that’s all I ever expected it to be. It took some time for me too, but I finally learned that Ninja can’t really walk on water.
After seeing the show, I finally got to learn where Jason and Bill were spending their all their time that week, and there were some “interesting” additions to the Ninja tradition (I did not know that Koppojutsu was Ninja Knife Fighting). Well done on the obstacle course. If anything is a motivation, it is doing everything you can to avoid falling in that water. From what I remember from 18 years ago, when I tried to be a Ninja too, I fell in, and nobody who sit next next to me on the train back to Noda. And I don’t think anybody as been back to the course since.
To the local BK guys who participated, a job well done and thanks for having the guts to do the job when requested to do so. Thanks to Yost for his support and great hosting skills.
By the way, we have a new idea for the next challenge, it will be combat with keyboards so all you masters out there, now is your chance to save the world!
Luckily I don’t have to miss a day at work again this time.
Buffu Ikkan
December 16, 2007 at 4:58 pm
I thought the episode was decent… I think for me the real question is regarding the prep work they do for the show now. I have watched alot of the other episodes in interest, but not having a solid background in many of the arts they showcase I always just assumed things were reasonably on point. After this show though now I am not sure how off base the other episodes were either…
I have seen the koppojutsu teacher in magazines and books over there for 15 years or so, but never associated him with ninjutsu… the kenjutsu teacher seemed to come in out of left field too. I guess you could make a very stretched case for the Meifu Shinkage Ryu but still.
Oh well, good job on the challenge… I got a big grin on my face when you were chain throwing the senban at him.
December 16, 2007 at 6:03 pm
Hi Doug,
I watched the episode last night and I enjoyed it. It was mostly pretty silly - but this was a mass market entertainment show, not a documentary and so the makers had to play up some of the sillier aspects of the ninja image.
I thought Yost did a good job, and both yourself and Bruce also did good jobs, given that you were doing something for the first time. (It would be a shame if people viewing the show thought obstacle courses and weapon sparring competitions are par for the course in the BJK, but again, it did make for entertaining television so I don’t think there is any real harm in it.) Soke’s comments in the interview section were interesting as well.
The hosts seem like nice guys and Jason is obviously a skilled martial artist in his own right, but they both seemed to ‘get’ that if the challenge had used real weapons, it would have been quite different. I think it showed guts to step up and mostly it seemed like a fun exercise for a fun show. Well done!
Alex
December 16, 2007 at 9:38 pm
Doug,
I enjoyed the show. I was a bit suprised with the “other”aspects of ninjutsu, but hey, it was interesting tv. I’m suprised most people didn’t notice that it was the hosts of the show that needed all the ice. Hmmmm.
Hope to see you in the Pac Northwest soon. Maybe we can run into each other this summer when come over.
Take care,
Phil
Cascade Tenchijin Dojo
December 17, 2007 at 2:56 am
Doug, I think the big question a lot of non BJK viewers and even BJK members are hoping to get just a slight insight into is why you dropped your weapon and ran in on a “grappler/MMA” guy.
This is not a critique at all but more of an effort to understand what it is you saw at that moment or what it was that may have prompted you to go for something that may have “dissipated” by the time you got in? More of a learning request than any sort of criticism. This lesson could be particularly important.
By the way it think it’s clear that both you and Bruce scored first so to speak. That’s what matters. I think all things considered it was an entertaining “TV” show.
December 17, 2007 at 3:21 am
Doug,
I really enjoyed seeing you on the show. As always, your work was brave, well done, and full of flavor. If anyone is going to nit pick perhaps they should consider the outcome of the match if points were awarded for nicely dropping the end of your bo on Jason’s toki.
December 17, 2007 at 7:17 am
sir, your all posts are excellent.
December 17, 2007 at 6:30 pm
Doug,
I really enjoyed watching you on the show. I thought that the match was nicely done for short notice. I really think your budo and spirit is very inspiring.
December 17, 2007 at 6:42 pm
Some have said that people shouldn’t be graded on ‘heart’ alone in the Bujinkan. Fair enough, I say, but in that case let no one advance in rank without it. You, clearly, have heart to match your rank and then some. No other student of Hatsumi soke that I am aware of, past or present, has put his or her experience and name on the line in so public a way (and so gracefully weathered the resulting commentary) since Stephen Hayes successfully took out his target on his own History Channel encounter. Cheers and Happy Training ALWAYS!
December 19, 2007 at 2:53 am
Doug, great job on the show! Super Smooth (as always). Hope to see you soon on the seminar circuit over here, maybe we can find some Yebisu again!
December 20, 2007 at 7:54 pm
I was so excited about this show (even I am from Istanbul) and I think you both did good job, I wish I could see behind the camera as well. I really enjoyed your using bo, sword and senban. I just thought ”why need for grappling?” but I see that your comment here explains everything. It was a brave thing to do sth. like this in front of a big audience (t.v.) I think you played with the guy as you can only use your Bo and can get him that way easier.It was entertaining, thank you. Hope to see you in Japan.
Ercan
Bujinkan Turkiye Dojo
January 3, 2008 at 5:27 pm
Wow Doug! that was amazing!!
I love what they say after the session…
They look very surprised…
A big Hug from south america!
see you in february!
And a happy new year!!!
David