Rank-What is that?

     The ranking system in the Bujinkan often receives criticism and it has been an area of discussion and controversy.

Regardless of the thinking or the reality, many put value and emphasis on rank.  However, when it comes down to it what does it really mean or matter to us or to Soke?

Soke said a recent training session that you should know your own rank as well as know your own limitations and expertise as well.

You should know what your rank is and therefore what your responsibilities are and ultimately what you represent.  You should train at a pace that is suitable for you.

So, I’m going to make a risky assumption here and say that rank in the BK has nothing to do with skill.  Skill based rank is limited and may well be the point of confusion.

Other martial arts that I have trained in, assign rank according to skill, how many techniques you know, how solid your form is etc.

Most of the leaders outside of Budo that I have had the honor to be around, have risen up the “ranks” of leadership on the basis of responsibility, ethical prowess, and pure ability to inspire and motivate people.  Honestly, these people are not always the most skillful people in the group, but have the innate ability to lead and get the job done.

Imagine the warrior on the battlefield who does not have the best skills or marksmanship, but has the guts to advance, lead people and obtain targets.  What takes this warrior places is not the skills, but the guts and the confidence to get the job done.

I truly believe that the above example is the closer to Soke’s intention when he gives rank.  It is not skill based. However, having rank is a responsibility that drives us to train harder to live up to our level.  Similar to the story that Soke told me about what he did when he was given the Sokeship from Takamatsu sensei. The only way to be worthy of his title was to train, train, train.

Soke also said at the recent DKMS that people are not perfect, and that it is immature to look through eyes that expect perfection.  What you see, most of the time, is not the truth.  So, if ones jumps to conclusions and takes action based on what is seen, it will most likely be the wrong action.  You need to use all your senses to perceive and therefore avoid taking action that can lead you astray.

It is my humble opinion, but I truly believe that when we obtain rank in the Bujinkan that it is not based on skill, but ability to be an ethical, just, diplomatic, and a leader who can do good for the world.

Skills can be developed through training, if you keep going.

 There is nothing more valuable than experience, and the only way to gain that is by living.

11 Responses to “Rank-What is that?”

  1. Martin Dunsky Says:

    Mr. Wilson,

    Thank you for a concise and clear explination for a topic near to my heart. I think the western concept of getting a diploma after you have completed something also confuses the picture.

    As a physician, I know alot of great doctors that give great care. I also know of quite a few Bozos that do not. I am also familiar with many nurses and physician assistants who I would much rather care for me than some of the Bozo’s, but they do not have the Medical Diplomas to be called doctors.

    You have to know the skills of the mechanic you go to, the doctors you see, and the teachers you go to!

    Marty

  2. Nikolaj Kielland Says:

    Hi Doug & everyone else reading this blog,

    I live in India and run the only Bujinkan Dôjô in the country. I will not presume to know much, I am still young and have only 9 years of experience in Bujinkan, I have come to Japan 5 times in 3 years and can not be seen as anyone else but someone who believes in the good that training in Bujinkan can lead to.

    After this DKMS I had the feeling that it is time to stop my (until now) introspection (i.e. am I good, are they good, I don’t understand, will I ever learn, when will I get promoted etc.) and begin to look at how to use the network, the skills and the knowledge for the good of society.

    I believe we have a responsibility as practitioners of Bujinkan to network when meeting for events as DKMS or the various Tai Kai round the world. Through these informal chats we get to know how many people who have dedicated their lives to teaching the skills and knowledge they have outside the Bujinkan. I was amazed this time to learn how many individuals who have made it their lives to help society, whether it be women, marines, FBI, hospitals or other organisations, using the teachings of sôke.

    To me, and to the others like me, networking with these individuals is an essential part of the training, so that we can bring them to our countries and implement their programmes for the better of society.

    To me this is also what Bujinkan is about.

    All the very best,

    Nikolaj

  3. ricardo Says:

    About Grades:

    A few years ago I traveled to Japan to train with Dr. Hatsumi;
    I was given a 3rd dan and a Shidoshi-ho, I went back home and
    trained and taught for almost 30 hours a week to deserve this grade.
    Possibly the happiest day of my life was my Godan test, Sensei painted
    a Fu (wind) character for me during the Tai Kai’s final supper, my Mom
    is a graduate from Art History when she saw the painting she said it
    is got the best done traces she has ever seen (beleive me - she has seen a lot).

    One day training in Japan another member of Bujinkan during the start
    of the session went for my elbow with a Musha-Dori and almost broke it.
    For many years I had to follow treatment for this injury. This technique was done
    in regular training session not during a fight (so he caught me in a trusting mode
    and I conciouslly never did nothing to put his person in danger),
    I still consider this treason and cowardice but have long forgived him;
    a few days later I heard he hated me since we arrived to Japan with the
    same grade but Sensei gave me a higher grade than him and he felt he had trained
    longer than I. Now I stand in the other side of the barrel: I fell serioulsy ill
    and have undergone a long treatment being unable to travel to Japan up until
    2 years ago. Some of the people I trained a few years back have now got higher grades
    than me. ?? Maybe I should feel jealous or angry ??.

    Surprisingly I am a happy man with a positive attitude (not because I’m
    a superman but because I have learned from Sensei’s words, making a negative
    situation into a positive one, turning a war into positive facts or situations,
    etc. Are we Budokas or a bunch of clowns running around in black gees ?.

    Name it; I have probalbly gone through it (positive and negative), today’s
    use of Budo in the big cities and normal situations is through the inner
    part and rarely through physical action, I have sadly been invloved in more
    than one life and death violent situation and like in the letter I wrote to Soke
    (publshed in Sanmyaku volume 2) I told Sensei I begged God not to have to fight.
    I wasn’t aware of my grade at those times, rather I was lucky enough to merge
    into KU and respond … (I’m still here). Did grade matter ???

    Today when I try to find out why Sensei does or says something I try
    to learn why he does it, remember of Kyojutsu, try to use my little
    knowlege of Japanese traditions and Ninjutsu and assume that one day I
    showed up for training (nobody invited me), and that every time I step
    into a Bujinkan Dojo when Sensei or the top Japanese Shihans are
    present I always ask for permission to enter.

    I sugest to read Sensei’s books, listen to him closely and
    as this is Doug’s blog thank him and the other translators (present
    and past) who do a wonderfull and very difficult job getting Sensei’s
    words to our language - believe me Sensei uses very rare words
    and expressions from Old Japan and you must be very close to Sensei
    to be able to translate fluently. I remenber before one of the Spanish
    Tai Kais I had to be 2 or 3 days reading Sensei’s books and lookig at videos
    of other Tai Kais to be prepared for the event, and many times feel
    I could have done a better job, but what I am sure of is that I
    did my best at the time and am at peace with meeself, I thank Sensei
    and Buijiakan for the opportunity to learn and live with this Martial
    Art and many of my Buyus throughout the world !

    R. Gonzalez.

  4. Robert Österman Says:

    I must comment on this, even though it’s not new anymore and I don’t know if anyone will read it.

    I recived 5 kyu last week (yep I’m pretty new) and the same thought that have gone through my head every time I move up a grade came again to no surprise; Now I got to earn this, live up to this.

    I read this and thought it funny cause I’ve always thought of my grade as a responsebilety, that I have to live up to it, sooner then thinking that I’ve already earned it when I recive it.

    This don’t add much I know, but I just felt I should reply.

    Thanks for a great site, I don’t have the oppertunity to travel to Japan, at least not for some time. And it means alot to me to still be able to get to know some of the wisdom Soke provides.

  5. Kerry Carper Says:

    I really enjoyed reading this. It’s puts things into a more realistic perspective for me.

    Thank you~

  6. Justyn Olby Says:

    Just wanted to say that this is a great piece on Bujinkan ranks, something that I will direct people to.
    Justyn

  7. Leaf Says:

    I was told once by my teacher(s) - “your belt and your patch should not just be a marker of what you can do, but what you can take”.

    Apply this not just to taijutsu but to attitude and spirit.

  8. Luis Garcia Says:

    Thank you for your piece. What should matter to everyone is not what your certificate states, but rather what your mind and spirit dictates. Set aside politics and continue training. If you are too concerned about rank, your training will suffer. Thank you once again and I wish everyone a healthy and rewarding New Year!

  9. Trevor Robinson Says:

    King Henry the Eight was a King and a Leader,

    He was also Hard as Nails, A great fighter and the best horseman in England,
    Personally I will not follow my inferior (and I dont mean just fighting) But I will learn By him. And I know many othesr Who are with me on that.
    Trevor Robinson Shidoshi.

  10. Eva Bodogan Says:

    Hello Doug,

    This was a great one about the ranks and I wish more people would read it (and with an open mind).

    I have recently attended a foreign seminar where I got to talk to the host (15th dan) about this rank issue. I wholeheartedly agree with what he said. Briefly it was that unfortunately majority of nowadays’ MA people give and take ranks as a sign of something they have already achieved.
    This is a wrong approach because it closes the doors to further things that could be learned, as it represents something which is already completed.
    Instead of this, ranks should be given and taken as a “hint” for something that you must accomplish, so it should be something to point forward and show you the direction where you have to focus and pursue training.
    So it makes it a neverending journey :-)

    Eva

  11. Henrik Hojager Says:

    HI all

    Just a quick comment on ranks.
    I can only agree with the above mentioned 15.Dan. I have always seen my own ranks as backpacks. Once I receive a rank, I am grateful, but at the same time I know, I am responsible for “putting in” stuff, that fulfills the rank.
    I, and only I, am responsible for every second of my life, (as are you) and what I allow to be part of it. It IS a neverending journey, and it’s wonderful :)

    Bufu Ikkan
    Henrik, Shidoshi

Leave a Reply